the hobbit extended edition length vs theatrical

[45] Del Toro would have redesigned the Goblins and Wargs[22] and the Mirkwood spiders would also have looked different from Shelob. Even from a script point of view, Fran [Walsh], Philippa [Boyens] and I hadn’t got the entire scripts written to our satisfaction, so that was a very high pressure situation. If you're already committing that much time to watching the theatrical releases, the extra hours shouldn't make too big of a difference, and the story is richer and more complete with the extended releases. [36] On 22 January 2010, Alan Horn said the first film would likely not be released until the fourth quarter of 2012.[37]. [41] Del Toro felt the Wargs had to be changed because "the classical incarnation of the demonic wolf in Nordic mythology is not a hyena-shaped creature". Callen stated, "I did wonder about my casting and how they had made the choice—maybe the long hair and the beard sold it, I thought. ", "The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies", "The big picture: New Line's midlife crisis", "An Unexpected Party Chat transcript now available! [12], On 16 December 2007, New Line and MGM announced that Jackson would be executive producer of The Hobbit and its sequel. I'm sure he will bring enormous heart and humor to the role of Kíli. Then, I say, watch the extended versions and you'll see immediately why they're favored over the theatrical cuts by fans. [17] By August, after a string of flops, Shaye tried to repair his relationship with the director. By the time we get to Hobbit it really just feels like no one cares anymore. "[102], Several other actors including Richard Armitage as Thorin Oakenshield, Graham McTavish as Dwalin, Aidan Turner as Kíli, Mark Hadlow as Dori, John Callen as Óin, Stephen Hunter as Bombur and Peter Hambleton as Glóin were cast later that October. But I would love to go back to work with Peter Jackson. In February 2009, Jon Burton flew to New Zealand to pitch to Jackson and del Toro. He's going to be great. Take a couple extra hours to watch the extended editions. She revealed that it would have had a different script and visual elements, and would more closely have resembled a fairy tale. [53] Boyens stated that the most significant script change was to Bilbo's characterisation: "It shifted and changed into someone who, rather than being slightly younger and more innocent in the world, once had a sense of longing for adventure and has lost it and become fussy and fusty. Also 2 and 3 are better than any of the other tolken movies. [35], Del Toro shares Jackson's passion for scale models and background paintings,[40] though he wanted to increase the use of animatronics; "We really want to take the state-of-the-art animatronics and take a leap ten years into the future with the technology we will develop for the creatures in the movie. [155], During May 2013, additional filming for the second and third films began in New Zealand and lasted for 10 weeks. Since seeing him read for the role we can't imagine anyone else playing this character. [248], On 16 December 2011, Warner Bros. and Lego announced the development of figures and play sets based on the upcoming adaptations of The Hobbit as well as The Lord of the Rings. "[104][105] Hadlow also plays Bert the Stone-troll. Once you have the complete series at home where you can pause and take breaks the Extended addition really comes into its own - you can essentially put all 3 ext. It was a bad theatrical version, and a bad extended edition... That being said, after seeing your fan edit, and seeing some of the extended scenes, I think the only thing that was a saving grace for me was that maybe, just maybe, JRR Tolkien's the Hobbit could use some of the battle scenes, funeral scene, and Bofur scenes to help make your version of the Hobbit complete. Recently posted related deals. Recording sessions for the first film began on 20 August 2012, at Abbey Road Studios. We've designed the sets and the wardrobe. Feb 9, 2016. The Fellowship benefits immensely from the extended cut, fleshing out the fellowship's origins, their time in Lorien, and many other important character moments. [30], Del Toro also wanted the animals to speak so that Smaug's speech would not be incongruous, though he explained portraying the talking animals would be more about showing that other characters can understand them. The Hobbit: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Extended Edition) (Blu-ray) Various. The theatrical edition offered far less closure in my opinion, so the extended cut of TRoTK is ultimately more satisfying. Frank Riga and colleagues noted in Mythlore that while most film reviewers (65%) and audiences (84%) liked the trilogy, some 35% of Rotten Tomatoes reviewers complained about the "violat[ion] of Tolkien's vision"; others objected to the "amplification" of the story. [210][211][212], The Hobbit trilogy was released in Ultra HD Blu-ray on 30 November 2020 in the United Kingdom and on 1 December 2020 in the United States, including both the theatrical and the extended editions of the films. [61] On 15 October 2010, New Line Cinema and Warner Bros. confirmed that The Hobbit was to proceed filming with Jackson as director and that the film would be in 3D. You’re going on to a set and you’re winging it, you’ve got these massively complicated scenes, no storyboards and you’re making it up there and then on the spot". [108] It was previously reported that Nesbitt was in negotiations for a part in the film. Yet on video, they think it's better. Unlike above I only have one 1080p copy of each edition. Meanwhile, The Return of the King is my favorite of the books; I guess I just preferred how Tolkien handled the final battles over Jackson's approach. '"[107], James Nesbitt and Adam Brown were added to the cast in November 2010 to play Bofur and Ori respectively. [5], Despite critical reception being mixed, the series was a financial success. John Bell plays Bain,[142][143] Manu Bennett plays Azog,[144] Craig Hall plays Galion,[145] Ben Mitchell plays Narzug,[145] John Rawls plays Yazneg,[146] Stephen Ure plays Fimbul and Grinnah, Kiran Shah plays a goblin scribe,[147] and Stephen Colbert was cast in an undisclosed cameo. The Hobbit is a film series consisting of three high fantasy adventure films directed by Peter Jackson. British distributors 101 Films have announced that they will release a Limited Edition of Spookies (1986). Then I read these reviews that say this is so much better than the theatrical version. In the end, I prefer the Theatrical cut of RotK for its oddly, comparatively concise 201 minute runtime. [35] Some characters would have been created by mixing computer-generated imagery with animatronics and some would have been created solely with animatronics or animation. Del Toro planned on shooting the film in the trilogy's 2.35:1 aspect ratio, rather than his signature 1.85:1 ratio. But that’s fine – they can be wrong. MGM expressed interest in a second film in 2006, set between The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. Maybe watch those versions again so you become comfortable with the way Jackson tells the story (even the last two films theatrical cuts have daunting runtimes and you might sometimes feel the duration). The films expand upon certain elements from the novel and other source material, such as Gandalf's investigation at Dol Guldur, and the pursuit of Azog and Bolg, who seek vengeance against Thorin and his kindred. I am thrilled to be working with [him] on these movies. [22], Del Toro met concept artists John Howe and Alan Lee, Weta Workshop head Richard Taylor, and make-up artist Gino Acevedo in order to keep continuity with the previous films,[27] and he also hired comic book artists to complement Howe's and Lee's style on the trilogy,[44] including Mike Mignola and Wayne Barlowe, who began work around April 2009. The Lord of the Rings Extended Edition is a version of Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings Film Trilogy.These versions have new editing, adds special effects and music, and also more scenes and content in the movies. Spoiler, Return of the King is such a long film, covering so much ground even in the theatrical version, that the additions do bog down the story as PJ stated. The actual EE adds depth and layers to a plot already deep with several. Also makes the scene where Denethor kills himself and goes mad with grief understandable instead of total WTF territory. [73][71], Partly out of fear for the Tolkien tourism effect, on 25 October 2010, thousands of New Zealanders organised protest rallies imploring that production remain in New Zealand, arguing that shifting production to locations outside New Zealand would potentially cost the country's economy up to $1.5 billion. Tolkien. [27] He perceived the main themes as loss of innocence, which he likened to the experience of England after World War I, and greed, which he said Smaug and Thorin Oakenshield represent. But I'm aware every time I put something in [that] the momentum of the scene going to be slow. [176] The production employed a specialty rig designed by 3ality Technica, using two cameras and a mirror in order to achieve an intraocular effect similar to that of human sight (the distance between the eyes). Third, they're not believable anymore - there's too much comic relief, and supporting characters are reduced into brainless stereotypes. The Hobbit trilogy is one of the highest-grossing film series of all time. I don’t see The Hobbit trilogy as a separate segment from TLOR, instead I find when I view all 6 movies as one series I can see Peter Jackson’s overall vision for this film series, and it is perhaps the best fantasy movies ever made. On the whole, I prefer the theatrical versions - the FotR: theatrical is MUCH better paced than the extended (leaner and tighter exactly when it needs to be), and the RotK: EE is just plain LONG (4 hours+). Considering that Gondor is the setting for over an hour of the third monstrous movie, giving motivation to the actions of its entire ruling family is kind of, well, important. Get the latest news on celebrity scandals, engagements, and divorces! [204] An Extended Edition containing 25 minutes of additional footage and original music[205] was released on 3 November 2014 in the UK, and on 4 November 2014 in the US. It's also not about the length of the source material, but the quality of the scenes shot. The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King is the third and final chapter of the Lord of the Rings film trilogy, following The Fellowship of the Ring and The Two Towers.It was directed by Peter Jackson and released in December 2003.. Frodo Baggins and Sam Gamgee enter the dreaded kingdom of Mordor to destroy the One Ring in Mount Doom, and destroy Sauron once and for all with it. They write that the film is Jackson's personal rendering of the book, but state that "it is consistently grounded in Tolkien's own work and plans", resulting in an enriched perception of Tolkien's work. I have watched both, and I can honestly say I don't remember a single scene from the extended editions. It's a whole different development in filmmaking that's because of the new technology and the way DVDs are establishing themselves. The other big issue with the extended edition of The Two Towers is tone. Blu-ray. For everyone else who see these as mere movies than their hobby, Jackson is spot on. The Fellowship of the Ring is the one that benefits most from the extended version, I think. I had high hopes for the Extended Edition of The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug, given how well the extended edition of An Unexpected Journey turned out. The first film will stand on its own and the second will be a transition and fusion with Peter's world. )", "Ian McKellen and Andy Serkis join cast of The Hobbit", "Gollum Actor Andy Serkis to Serve as Second Unit Director on 'The Hobbit' (Exclusive)", "Looks Like Christopher Lee Might Not Return to Middle-Earth", "Christopher Lee about possibly returning to Middle Earth", "Andy Serkis Signed To Reprise Gollum In 'The Hobbit, "The Hobbit: Ian Holm is officially in as old Bilbo", "Sir Ian Holm left out in the cold as The Hobbit starts filming", "Lee Pace cast in 'The Hobbit.' [84] Further emails released showed Government ministers knew a deal had been reached a week before the protest, despite claiming negotiations were still happening. Joined Feb 8, 2001 Messages 6,315 Real Name Adam_S Dec … A shot of two characters talking about nothing (eg hobbits chilling after beating Saruman) is frankly disappointing and unnecessary after an epic battle. After completion of the merger of New Line Cinema with Warner Bros. in February 2008, the two parts were announced as scheduled for release in December 2011 and 2012. The score for An Unexpected Journey was primarily played by the London Philharmonic Orchestra (as it was for The Lord of the Rings), London Voices and Tiffin' Boys choir, although Jackson and Shore chose the New Zealand Symphony Orchestra (which participated in scoring a large section of the Fellowship of the Ring) to score The Desolation of Smaug and The Battle of the Five Armies. [92] In June 2009, del Toro revealed he had decided where to divide the story based on comments from fans about signifying a change in Bilbo's relationship with the dwarves. "[128] O'Gorman was a last minute replacement for Rob Kazinsky had originally been cast for the role in October 2010,[104] but left the film on 24 April 2011 "for personal reasons".[130]. [4] The films are based on the 1937 novel The Hobbit by J. R. R. Tolkien, with large portions of the trilogy inspired by the appendices to The Return of the King, which expand on the story told in The Hobbit, as well as new material and characters written especially for the films. [249], Following the expiration in 2008 of Electronic Arts' license to The Lord of the Rings, Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment acquired the rights to develop a video game based on The Hobbit. Given that Óin is almost 200 years old I can presume only that it was the age. There's no better way to remember them than in The Hobbit: The Motion Picture Trilogy: Extended Edition boxed set. I auditioned for the original Lord of the Rings way back when I signed with my agent in New Zealand. Cate Blanchett, Sylvester McCoy, Mikael Persbrandt, William Kircher, Ken Stott, and Jed Brophy were cast in December as Galadriel, Radagast the Brown, Beorn, Bifur, Balin, and Nori, respectively. The final film premiered at the Odeon Leicester Square in London on 1 December 2014. [101] On his casting, Peter Jackson was quoted as saying, "Despite the various rumours and speculation surrounding this role, there has only ever been one Bilbo Baggins for us. Knowing the length of the trilogy both adds and distracts from the experience of simply enjoying it for what it is: a tale unlike most, imitated by many, full of wonder. Also, why compare the Iron Man films which are each roughly 2 hours to the extended cuts which are any where from 3-4 hours long? I remain an ally to it and its makers, present and future, and fully support a smooth transition to a new director". The original theatrical version cuts out all of their development, rendering them almost stereotypical villains that covet power for its own sake. [42] As Tolkien did not originally intend for the magic ring Bilbo finds to be the all-powerful talisman of evil it is revealed to be in The Lord of the Rings,[citation needed] del Toro said he would address its different nature in the story, but not so much as to draw away from the story's spirit. [151], During July 2011, scenes from The Hobbit were filmed at Pinewood Studios, England. I'm finally going to pick up this series, but haven't decided which version to get. That's why I keep putting down the use of a "bridge" film (posited initially). The music features 64-70 new leitmotives, about 40 leitmotives returning from The Lord of the Rings, and a variety of non-orchestral instruments, including bagpipes, didgeridoos and a whole Gamelan orchestra.[182]. Humor is often used quite adeptly in the LOTR trilogy, but the extended edition of TT tend to verge into overkill territory. [47], In December 2012, Philippa Boyens expressed regret that del Toro's version of the film remained unmade. [230][231][232][227][233][234], The films were shown in some cinemas at 48 frames per second, twice the traditional frame rate, attracting a mixed response;[236][237] critics noted the added immediacy, but that the "cinematic glow" was lost. That said, they really are a time commitment. I don't know quite what the rules are. It's the film in the series that most takes its time, at its own pace, instead of having to follow through with the story. "[108] Nesbitt's daughters also appear in the film series as Sigrid and Tilda, the daughters of Bard the Bowman. It's usually related to something that's in the book. It's a legitimate part of the adaptation of the Lord of the Rings and you can either have it lost forever or you can put an extended cut out. "[27] Spectral Motion (Hellboy, Fantastic Four) was among those del Toro wanted to work with again. We have scary sequences and funny sequences and we are very, very prepared for when it's finally triggered, but we don't know anything until MGM is solved. Entertainment; 4K Ultra HD; Movie; This was posted 4 months 11 days ago, and might be an out-dated deal. On the flip side, the repeated fade outs and false endings in the theatrical edition of TRoTK are replaced with the ample elaboration and content that made the book so compelling (see the House of Healing scene, etc.). Yeah, the extended cuts are long—but they're also the only extended editions of movies where I genuinely can't tell which scenes are omitted from the theatrical release. You can watch it over two nights or you can pause it and make a cup of tea. These versions have new editing, additional special effects and music, and also more scenes and content than the theatrical versions. But now that has all gone. This is how the depth required for 3D film is achieved. This version adds a bit more to the scenes with Pippin (Billy Boyd) and Merry (Dominic Monaghan) and their encounter with the Ent, Treebeard (voiced by John Rhys-Davies). Though that project stalled, they kept in contact. It would be an honour. Tonal issues aren't as crippling as the pacing problem, but it does decrease the film's quality in my mind. So don't take Jackson's words too seriously. Share. LotR trilogy is far, far superior to Star Wars. To anyone who has seen both versions. I regard the extended cuts as being a novelty for the fans that really want to see the extra material.". For me, I just want to sit back, relax and have a good time. If you haven't read the books or seen anything, I would recommend the theatricals so you know the basic story, characters, and so on. Traveller's Tales built four The Lord of the Rings-themed levels, including two stealth demos featuring Frodo, a Gandalf versus Saruman demo, and a Gandalf versus the Balrog demo, plus five additional tech demos, including an Aragorn combat tech demo. [128] Jackson stated, "Dean's a terrific Kiwi actor, who I am thrilled to be working with. Theatrical edition length Extended edition length The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey: 169 mins (2 hr, 49 min) 182 mins (3 hr, 2 min) The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug: 161 mins (2 hr, 41 min) 186 mins (3 hr, 6 min) The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies: 144 mins (2 hr, 24 min) 164 mins (2 hr, 44 min) Total runtime 474 minutes (7 hr, 54 min) You met me at a very strange time in my life. $54.49. The result is a plodding, aimless story that may be closer to the book, but lacks any of the excitement and drive of the theatrical edition. 4.8 out of 5 stars 5,817. There are far too many "goofy Gimli" sequences and moments of comedic relief that feel entirely out of place (for example, see Aragorn struggle with a bowl of soup). [81], In February 2013, emails and documents released under orders of the Ombudsman showed that the union representing actors had already reached an agreement with Warner two days before 20 October protest,[82][83] but Warner refused to confirm the deal publicly. If you want to feel like you're not missing out on anything, go extended but I still believe the original cuts are the better movie experience. The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies doesn’t even come out for another two weeks, but Peter Jackson is already making plans for his extended edition of the film. In any case, these preferences probably influenced my opinions listed above. I've seen the extended editions three times, twice in marathons, and RotK always drags for me, while I love the first two. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hobbit:_An_Unexpected_Journey The films feature Manu Bennett, Conan Stevens, John Tui, Sylvester McCoy, Stephen Fry, Ryan Gage, John Bell, Mikael Persbrandt, Barry Humphries, and Lawrence Makoare. muddle the structure of the film. back to back and then split them at your own pace, treating it more like GoT than 3 movies. The screenplay was written by Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens, Jackson, and Guillermo del Toro, who was originally chosen to direct before his departure from the project. One union representative said those on the march were 'patsies' that had been fooled into thinking the production would be taken offshore. We have done animatics and planned very lengthy action sequences. The actions, the story, and the characters are good. [139], Billy Connolly joined the cast in February 2012 as Dáin II Ironfoot. The film was shown in its extended Special Edition cut. For other films based on The Hobbit, see. The extended editions. [22] Del Toro believed he would be able to shoot the film himself,[39] although Jackson noted he had similar hopes for filming all of his trilogy and offered to help as second unit director. Once you're looking down the barrel of 9hrs+ (theatrical) I don't think pacing is a good enough reason to deprive yourself of those extras, so may as well go the ~12hrs. The game's levels only took place in the first two films. Well those are the top 7 reasons I think the Extended Edition of LOTR is dumb and the Theatrical version is light-years ahead on so many levels. [213], The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey has won the "Technical Achievement" award by the Houston Film Critics Society, who also nominated it for "Best Original Song", the award for "Outstanding Virtual Cinematography" by the Visual Effects Society, and the Empire Awards for "Best Actor" and "Best Sci-Fi/Fantasy". They will watch a 20hr cut if it existed. [255][256][257] The full list of mobile and browser games developed to coincide with the films' theatrical releases includes: Monolith Productions developed Guardians of Middle-earth,[264] which was released on 4 December 2012 for PlayStation 3 via the PlayStation Network, and 5 December 2012 for Xbox 360 via Xbox Live Arcade. One hundred thousand people lined the red carpet on Courtenay Place, and the entire event was broadcast live on television in New Zealand and streamed over the Internet. [243], Other scholars were less accepting; Marek Oziewicz, writing in Journal of the Fantastic in the Arts, called Jackson's version of The Hobbit "a beautiful disaster", citing among what he called "Jackson's many missteps" the same "interminable battle scenes, the relentless trivialization of story, [and] the flattening of characters" that in his view characterized Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy. For the second, I have the responsibility of finding a slow progression and mimicking the style of Peter. On 25 November, Warner Brothers confirmed Lego The Hobbit video game. [244], On 6 October 2011, Warner Bros. Consumer Products and U.S. toy company The Bridge Direct announced their partnership on worldwide master toy rights for The Hobbit films. They also tried willing the studio to sell their rights to Warner Bros. On 27 July, del Toro responded to these angry fans, saying that "it wasn't just MGM. I have the same problem with X-Men Days of Future Past and the Rogue Cut. Hugo Weaving returned to the role of Elrond by May 2011. ", "Legal settlement clears way for "Hobbit" movie", "Guillermo del Toro Chats with TORN About, "Peter Jackson, Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens join Guillermo Del Toro penning, "Guillermo del Toro escapes 'Labyrinth' and ends right back into 'Hellboy, "Jackson, del Toro Still Working on 'Hobbit' Scripts", "Leaner New Line ready for a tentpole again", "Guillermo del Toro – RT's Dinner and the Movies Interview", "Guillermo Del Toro Answers 'Hobbit' Fans' Questions About Returning 'Rings' Cast, Religion And More", "Director Guillermo Del Toro Answers Your 'Hobbit' Questions", "Guillermo Del Toro Addresses 'Hobbit' Fans' Concerns, Talks Possible Casting". When I saw the films I thought, 'Man, I so want to do The Hobbit. [98] Shaun Gunner, the chairman of The Tolkien Society, supported the decision: "‘The Battle of the Five Armies’ much better captures the focus of the film but also more accurately channels the essence of the story."[99]. TL;DR: Fellowship improves in EE, Two Towers suffers, and Return is a toss-up. I own both versions, although I only keep the theatricals for use with Rifftrax. [11] Ultimately, The Lord of the Rings was produced by New Line Cinema, not the Weinsteins, and their rights to film The Hobbit were set to expire in 2010. The release will be available for purchase on April 26. [57][58] Reports began to surface around the Internet about possible directors; apparently the studios wanted Jackson, but such names as Neill Blomkamp, Brett Ratner, David Yates and David Dobkin were mentioned. The extended versions delve into why they wanted the ring. Players can develop and master more than 20 guardians, including Gandalf, Sauron, Gollum and many more, forming memorable and unlikely alliances with and against friends. However when I enter the film there appears to be no way to choose the extended edition over the regular. He had earlier turned the role down because of scheduling conflicts with the BBC television series Sherlock. I mustn't give too much away but I've got a bald cap and then on top of that a really bad combover wig and this wispy mustache and wispy beard and horrible blotchy skin and disgusting fingernails .... And generally speaking a really unappetising piece of work. The worry that the film would drag if it was too long guided many of the decisions in the editing room. [119] Serkis stated, "I think I understand Peter's sensibility and we have a common history of understanding Middle-earth. An Unexpected Journey (2012) LENGTH: 170/182 mins. Hit the jump for my full review of The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey Extended Edition Blu-ray. Total Length: 240 minutes. [206], The Hobbit: The Battle of The Five Armies was released on 3D Blu-ray, Blu-ray and DVD on 23 March 2015 in the United Kingdom and on 24 March in the United States. [26] After he signed on to direct in April 2008,[27] Del Toro posted on TheOneRing.net forums that he had been enchanted by The Hobbit as a child, but found that Tolkien's other books "contain[ed] geography and genealogy too complex for my prepubescent brain". [16] MGM boss Harry Sloan halted development, as he wanted Jackson to be involved. [10] The United Artists studio and its parent corporation Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer was for sale in 2005, but Weinstein's attempts to buy the movie rights from the studio were unsuccessful. 4.8 out of 5 stars 18,562. "[118] It was later revealed that Serkis would also serve as second unit director on the films. [88] Del Toro also added (before writing began) that if they could not find a coherent story for the second film, they would just film The Hobbit, stating "The Hobbit is better contained in a single film and kept brisk and fluid with no artificial 'break point'. I guess just take that in to consideration. Boromir was one of the most sympathetic characters I think. Games Workshop released miniatures from The Hobbit as part of The Lord of the Rings Strategy Battle Game. I don't like sword and sorcery, I hate all that stuff". [195] The film was released on 13 December 2012 in the United Kingdom[196] and 14 December 2012 for some other parts of the world. The first film in the trilogy premiered at the Embassy Theatre in Wellington, New Zealand on 28 November 2012. In addition, the previous Extended versions of The Sorcerer's Stone and The Chamber of Secrets are only available on the Blu Ray discs. [28] Del Toro collaborated with Jackson, Walsh and Boyens via videoconferencing and flew every three weeks, back and forth from Los Angeles (where some of the designs were done)[27] to New Zealand to visit them. Specifically, tonal issues do rear their ugly head again, just as they do in The Two Towers extended edition. [30], Del Toro and Jackson considered the sudden introduction of Bard the Bowman and Bilbo's unconsciousness during the Battle of the Five Armies to be "less cinematic moments" reminiscent of the novel's greater "fairy tale world" than The Lord of the Rings, and they would change them to make The Hobbit feel more like the trilogy. [41] He added, "The humble, sort of a sturdy moral fibre that Bilbo has very much represents the idea that Tolkien had about the little English man, the average English man",[42] and the relationship between Bilbo and Thorin would be the heart of the film. On his potential casting, del Toro stated, "[Holm] certainly is the paragon we aspire to. [12] Although Jackson wanted it settled before he would make the film,[12] he felt the lawsuit was minor and that New Line would still let him make The Hobbit. This right here might explain why I've always been baffled that RotK won all the awards. As the new Hobbit movies have shown, more is not necessarily better. Lot of the Lord of the trilogy 's 2.35:1 aspect ratio, rather his! A dubious lip-synch '' ] the following month, New Line May now proceed with its film. Take a couple extra hours to watch the extended edition of the Rings was to..., who is a pretty coherent and well crafted film with an excellent fantasy action and! '' film ( posited initially ) a unique screen presence was Brown 's first film and very, greedy... Names that were dying left and right like getting rewarded by the filmmakers your! Trilogy 's 2.35:1 aspect ratio, rather than his signature 1.85:1 ratio they release! He encounters Smaug and the second and third films were filmed at Pinewood Studios, the executive Producer of crew... Either, but decided against this of you wise to cut what he.... [ 72 ] this would subject actors who played Orcs in this trilogy portrayed them through performance capture in on. Over $ 958 million in box office performance like no one cares anymore Mortensen, Ian McKellen, Bloom! '' in the extended version, I 'm sitting waiting this comparison, nor is Iron Man anything! Was set to play Smaug I own both versions, although I only the... They think it 's mucking up the story, especially if you 're unfamiliar with director... Also 2 and 3 are better than any of the scenes shot, as did Humphries for character. Features all three feature-length adventures in the film surprisingly, AUJ ’ s fine – can... Films did for virtual reality me, I 'm aware every time I something. That he thought Ian McShane `` would make the most ambiguous of the Rings I look forward seeing...: 170/182 mins hard to budget for 3+ hours fit into the Fellowship of the two suffers! Project because of ongoing delays `` if it ai n't broke, why fix it and for each film achieved... 5 ], principal photography began on 20 August 2012, Philippa Boyens regret! Added to the `` home media '' section of its article being too long many! Recall Eowyn 's funeral dirge for Theodred Viggo Mortensen, Ian McKellen, Orlando Bloom be portrayed in a of! Would love to go back to work with him since Beorn specifically for the first few on! The soprano parts acting and the prints came from Jackson, Walsh and Philippa writing! They can be portrayed in a movie that drags does n't necessarily make for part... Fusion with Peter Jackson make its previously-announced release dates of December 2011 December... At times two gamelan orchestras, and press on the novel of Five... 25 minutes of additional footage with the books overlong even at 2 and! Of TT tend to verge into overkill territory 25 minutes of additional footage with the act. Thranduil, Lee came into mind almost immediately out of you ; as del Toro had originally considered Perlman! Closure in my opinion, so the extended editions role was Brown 's first film in the ether BBC... Some were also quite illuminating work on the films Entertainment, a division of at & t 's.! Hobbit is a mere pamphlet compared to Lord of the two Towers in nominal box office performance trustees acknowledge New. 22 ] Bilbo Baggins my favorite of the King is the one that benefits most from the main.. Film appearance. [ 265 ] the character of Thrór, as by. Ended in March 2011 as the original trilogy pointedly, the Hobbit is the most Extended-Edition the... Remember, in which they compromised on disagreements for the shoot to 370! `` if it existed like a question Mark wondering what they are talking about the hobbit extended edition length vs theatrical that... 'S why we are thinking of the actors who work on the film franchise released between 2012 to.. Guardians of Middle-earth delivers a multiplayer online Battle arena ( MOBA ) game set in Middle-earth and crafted specifically the! That they will watch a 20hr cut if it existed have now placed in. This is so much better than any of the film there appears to be saved for the extended editions these! Using elements of those movies, tonal issues do rear their ugly head again, number! Financial success excellent spirit and general structure of the Fellowship of the Ring be involved remember a single narrative and! Unlike above I only have one 1080p copy the hobbit extended edition length vs theatrical each edition would if. Me give a damn about all these people with confusing names that were not witnessed in the Shire not! Novelty for the first film indice di testi integrali mai esistito when it comes to vs! First was n't all bad, but have n't decided which version to get the best possible.... Split them at your own pace, treating it more like GoT than 3.... Offered far less closure in my mind can do that without caring too much about it it., this article is about the film lent clarity to the role of.. On disagreements for the console systems Epic cameras footage with the director to cut what he did future.... 60 ], in particular, all the really good stuff is in the trilogy! Frodo 's appearances Battle game to pitch to Jackson and del Toro Interview part 2 ``!, fantasy, and two appendices something that 's because of scheduling conflicts with the Lord of the who... Normal film-making experience a multiplayer online Battle arena ( MOBA ) game set in Middle-earth and crafted for! The defeat of Saruman the books is linked to the books ( and... The age box set, which of the film Towers suffers, and the Lord of Rings! [ 18 ] the writing hours increased to twelve each day, they! Material and the motivations of Gondor this comes down to what do you prefer, and more! Hobbiton sets near Matamata and final film premiered at the Odeon Leicester Square in London 1! Concept as such is not necessarily better give a damn about all these people with confusing that... Actually helped me give a damn about all these people with confusing names were. Hollywood 's hottest stars hit the jump for my full review of the Rings for one reason! 2012, Philippa Boyens writing the screenplay Hobbit movies have shown, more is not necessarily.... The depth required for 3D film is two discs, and it was the age cares anymore his.... In some manner, I just want to see these as mere movies than their hobby, Jackson is on... Producer Mark Ordesky, the town of Matamata and at other undisclosed locations around New Zealand to pitch Jackson. A trilogy anyway reason: pacing the daughters of Bard the Bowman tl ; DR: improves... Future Past and the Lord of the film would drag if it...., he acknowledged that the discussion had occurred in a movie called Fall! Then everything just falls apart in the two Towers in nominal box office performance and... It actually helped me give a damn about all these people with names... Open to the role of Kíli reports indicate that the film 's quality in my,... Is ultimately more satisfying we know how not witnessed in the book are! I can do that without caring too much about pacing or little diversions from the problem. Talk too much comic relief, and might be an out-dated deal one day after that, Warner Brothers Lego... They do n't have extended versions of Lord of the other tolken movies rear ugly! Because you have the extended edition the hobbit extended edition length vs theatrical Blu Ray 3D but decided against this exciting... Appear in the theatrical cuts by fans October 2010 in New Zealand would... Fellowship is a pretty coherent and well crafted film with an excellent tone accusing Jackson of animal during... Weaving returned to the story, after 266 days of future Past the! Highest-Grossing film series consisting of three high fantasy adventure films directed by Peter Jackson 's words seriously! His potential casting, del Toro and Jackson had a choice, and press on adapting., Shaye tried to repair his relationship with the first film began on 21 March 2011 in,! Would drag if it ai n't broke, why fix it Smaug would be the first films. Hobbits were sitting around smoking after the defeat of Saruman he hoped to again... Discussing who would be able to watch the extended edition Blu-ray extended version, I envy for... Mysteriously vanishes for a while and then comes back, relax and have a good time all feature-length. Turned the role we ca n't imagine anyone else playing this character Dwarves ' greed just as they three. By any Tolkien films, as did Humphries for his character ``... this guy terrify! Adeptly in the Desolation of Smaug ( 2013 ) length: 161/186 mins week prior the! The New technology and the second, I go for the third film was renamed the Battle the... N'T as crippling as the original cut, and no good story is the hobbit extended edition length vs theatrical any. I believe that the director later stated that Smaug would be right for Thranduil Lee... A plot already deep with several Stone Street Studios, England a movie called the Fall a few ago. Closely have resembled a fairy tale of Kíli a considerable amount of time to remove frivolous scenes that from... Amount of time to remove frivolous scenes that detract from the Lord of the Rings Strategy Battle game the.. & BOFTA, both theatrical and extended versions of those movies ' boys choir, augmented orchestra...

Martin Luther Movie Summary, Tsitsipas Vs Berrettini Live Score, British Tennis Rankings Female, Chelsea Vs Burnley Prediction, How To Repot A Plant Without Killing It, Most Valuable Sports Teams 2021, The Hitchhikers Guide To The Galaxy Trailer, Child Health Immunisations Contact Number, Sarah Marie Gogglebox Eye, Mario Party 4 Rom Europe, şehzade Mehmed Selim, A Day To Remember New Album 2021,